
Introduction
Ari Aster, known for his deeply unsettling and boundary-pushing cinema such as Hereditary and Midsommar, returns with Eddington, an audacious and provocative neo-Western satire. Starring the ever-compelling Joaquin Phoenix and charismatic Pedro Pascal, the film navigates the treacherous waters of pandemic-era politics and societal division with sharp humor and biting commentary. Though occasionally uneven, Eddington succeeds as a daring exploration of American psychosis, delivering an intense, thought-provoking, and ultimately memorable cinematic experience.
Table of Contents
Story: A Powder Keg in a Small Town
Set in May 2020, the story centers on the sleepy town of Eddington, New Mexico. The tranquil facade crumbles dramatically when a standoff erupts between Sheriff Joe Cross (Joaquin Phoenix) and Mayor Ted Garcia (Pedro Pascal). This initial confrontation quickly escalates, igniting simmering tensions and turning neighbors against each other. What follows is a chaotic, gripping portrayal of how fear, misinformation, and ideological polarization rapidly unravel the social fabric of the community.
The narrative excels at capturing the paranoia and confusion of the early pandemic days. Aster expertly crafts scenes that reflect the absurdity and horror of our recent collective trauma, emphasizing how quickly ordinary people become pawns in a larger political game. The darkly comedic tone is perfectly suited for this material, ensuring that while viewers laugh at the absurdity, they simultaneously confront uncomfortable truths about human nature and societal breakdown.

Characters: Complex Figures in a Fractured Society
Joaquin Phoenix is magnetic as Sheriff Joe Cross, portraying a deeply flawed yet relatable character who embodies the frustration and confusion felt by many during the pandemic’s early stages. Phoenix pushes his performance to unsettling extremes, reminding audiences why he’s one of Hollywood’s most fearless actors. His descent from an authoritative figure into desperate paranoia is both gripping and tragic, anchoring the film’s emotional core.
Pedro Pascal is equally captivating as Mayor Ted Garcia, providing a nuanced foil to Phoenix’s more chaotic sheriff. Pascal brings charm and charisma to a character who slowly reveals darker, opportunistic tendencies. His portrayal effectively highlights how politicians manipulate crises for personal and political gain, adding layers of depth and intrigue to the story.
Emma Stone delivers a compelling performance as Louise Cross, Joe’s conflicted wife, who becomes ensnared in conspiracy theories, creating substantial tension within her family. Austin Butler convincingly portrays Vernon, a charismatic conspiracy theorist whose popular online platform criticizes pandemic-era policies, deeply influencing Louise and escalating tensions between her and Joe. Deirdre O’Connell’s portrayal of Dawn, Louise’s mother, is captivatingly manic and slightly detached from reality, illustrating how easily individuals can slip into paranoia, further amplifying household tension.
Direction: Ari Aster’s Bold and Uncompromising Vision
Ari Aster continues to demonstrate his unique ability to unsettle and provoke audiences with Eddington. His uncompromising direction crafts an uncomfortable yet riveting narrative. Aster balances humor and horror expertly, ensuring the film remains both entertaining and insightful. The film boldly addresses contemporary issues without offering easy solutions, instead plunging viewers into the depths of societal dysfunction.
While not every satirical element Aster employs fully lands, his willingness to experiment and challenge audience expectations remains commendable. His portrayal of pandemic-era America feels both relevant and necessary, reflecting a nation struggling to reconcile its collective trauma and deepening divisions.

Technical Details: Crafting Chaos Through Cinematic Brilliance
The film’s technical execution significantly enhances its narrative impact. Cinematographer Darius Khondji, collaborating with Aster, creates visually arresting sequences that amplify the narrative’s tension and absurdity. Khondji’s compositions expertly juxtapose wide, expansive landscapes against the claustrophobic interiors, effectively mirroring the film’s thematic contrasts between freedom and confinement, unity and division.
Composers Daniel Pemberton and The Haxan Cloak provide an unsettling yet fitting musical score that heightens the narrative’s emotional stakes. Their haunting and chaotic arrangements complement the film’s tone, underpinning moments of both humor and dread. The integration of music and visuals ensures that Eddington remains a deeply immersive and emotionally impactful experience.
Final Thoughts: Imperfect Yet Unforgettable
Eddington is not a perfect film, occasionally faltering as some of its satirical punches miss the mark. Nevertheless, Ari Aster delivers a fiercely relevant and engaging work that captures the absurdities and horrors of recent history. Anchored by powerhouse performances from Joaquin Phoenix and Pedro Pascal, the film offers viewers a disturbing yet hilarious reflection on contemporary America’s fractured psyche.
Ultimately, Eddington resonates as a cynical yet necessary exploration of societal dysfunction, exposing how quickly neighborly bonds dissolve under the pressure of ideological warfare. Ari Aster’s provocative vision ensures that, while the film is often uncomfortable to watch, it remains a compelling and unforgettable cinematic experience.
About “Eddington”
Synopsis: In May of 2020, a standoff between a small-town sheriff and mayor sparks a powder keg as neighbor is pitted against neighbor in Eddington, New Mexico.
Director: Ari Aster
Writer: Ari Aster
Cast: Joaquin Phoenix (Joe Cross), Pedro Pascal (Ted Garcia), Emma Stone (Louise Cross), Austin Butler (Vernon), Deirdre O’Connell (Dawn)
Rated: R for strong violence, some grisly images, language, and graphic nudity.
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Western
Runtime: 2h 28m
Releases: July 18, 2025

he/him • aapi • intj • geek • photographer • journalist • podcaster • martial artist • foodie • dj • cinephile • gamer • traveler